SEO Efforts Not Yielding Results

SEO Efforts Not Yielding Results?

Is your website buried deep in Google’s search results despite you investing a lot of time and money on SEO? You’re not by yourself. This is an irritatingly typical situation for a lot of people.

The art and science of increasing your website’s visibility through search engine optimization, or SEO, is crucial to the success of any modern organization. It’s an essential investment that will boost brand credibility, bring in more organic visitors to your website, and eventually boost revenue.

But what happens if it doesn’t look like the investment is paying off? We’ll assist you in evaluating your present SEO efforts in this blog and deciding whether a change is necessary.

Setting Realistic Expectations

Setting reasonable goals is essential when reviewing your SEO efforts. Understand that SEO is a long-term strategy that takes constant effort; it is not a fast fix. Before assuming that your SEO approach is working, give it some time to develop and provide results.

A multitude of factors can cause results to vary. A traffic decline of one month does not portend catastrophe. It’s critical to consider performance within the larger framework of historical patterns. A great SEO campaign is built on patience, testing, and frequent improvements based on data.

How long does it take for SEO to work?

SEO is a long-term commitment that usually yields returns in three to six months, with more notable outcomes frequently appearing after a year. The duration varies according to the size of the website, the industry, the level of competition, and other outside circumstances. Since SEO is a marathon rather than a sprint, persistence and patience are essential.

Can you predict SEO results?

Due to a variety of factors, including industry trends, algorithm updates, and competition, predicting SEO outcomes can be difficult. While seasoned SEO specialists are able to generate informed projections using data and patterns, complete certainty is unachievable. To determine whether SEO is actually effective or not, it’s critical to set realistic expectations.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to Monitor

The metrics you should track are determined by your SEO campaign’s objectives. Developing brand awareness and generating leads could call for distinct strategies. Because of this, the KPIs that are truly important will vary depending on your objectives.

It’s not always the end of the world when one KPI performs poorly. Instead, it’s a single component in the larger picture of how well your campaign performed.

The eight KPIs listed below can help you evaluate your SEO efforts.

Organic Traffic

The primary goal of SEO is to improve your site’s ranking in search engines, which makes organic traffic a crucial KPI. A steady rise in organic traffic indicates that your SEO efforts are having an impact and raising the exposure of your website. Examine a timeframe (3–12 months) and contrast it with the prior year to determine whether there have been any gains or losses.


Conversions are particular activities that website visitors take, like completing a form or making a purchase. One of the main objectives of SEO is to enhance conversions; as more focused traffic is brought in by your SEO efforts, more conversions ought to follow. Examine a broad variety of dates to determine whether this number is rising or falling over time, much like you would with organic traffic.

Keyword Rankings

This KPI monitors the overall number of keywords for which your website ranks as well as the average position for those terms. Using tools such as Ahrefs, Semrush, and Google Search Console to track these metrics will enable you to determine whether your site is performing better or worse in search results, which is a direct reflection of its SEO efforts. Examine how long you have been working with your SEO provider. What’s popular at the moment?

Domain Authority

Domain Authority (DA) is a measure of a website’s overall authority and a predictor of its chances of ranking higher than its rivals. You can gauge the general SEO health of your website by keeping an eye on whether your DA is increasing or decreasing. To find out how your domain’s DA has changed over time, use the Moz Domain Authority Checker. Has it increased? remained unchanged? lost its way?


Backlinks are urls pointing to your website from other websites. Due to their significant impact on rankings and contribution to domain authority, high-quality backlinks are essential. Utilize Moz, Ahrefs, or Semrush to analyze your backlink profile. Verify whether there are now more or fewer domains referring to you. To determine whether those domains are of a high caliber or not, look at their ratings. Getting solid backlinks from sites that are respected in your field ought to be the main goal of your SEO campaign.

Engagement Metrics

These KPIs track user behavior on your website, like time on page and engagement rate. Enhancing the user experience with effective SEO should entice users to stay on your website longer and eventually convert. View the performance of some of your most popular content by using Google Analytics. To determine whether these engagement indicators are trending in the right way, analyze the organic traffic over a period of several months.

Also Read: Guest Post Rejection: Reasons Why

Brand Mentions

Using tools like Moz’s Brand Authority or Google Alerts to track brand mentions can help you keep tabs on your brand’s increasing (or declining) online presence. Increased brand mentions are not exclusively related to SEO, but they do correlate with better online exposure.

Traffic Value

The “traffic value” indicator offered by Ahrefs calculates the possible worth of organic traffic to your website. Keeping an eye on this value’s growth or decline might provide you with valuable information about how well your SEO approach is working.

Leads and Sales

Increasing sales and generating more leads (phone calls, form submissions, emails, etc.) are the ultimate goals of SEO. Monitoring these indicators is essential to determining whether SEO efforts are yielding profitable results. However, without input from you, the business partner, tracking sales figures can be challenging. To assess the quality of the leads being generated, it is essential to share the percentage of leads that become sales. In order to determine whether leads and sales are rising, evaluate your internal sales figures and link them to website performance.

Organic Revenue

It’s critical for e-commerce sites to track organic revenue. This KPI, which directly correlates to revenue from organic search traffic, paints a clear picture of the return on investment (ROI) on SEO activities. Check Google Analytics to check if there has been an increase in revenue in the last three, six, or twelve months.

Note: Contextualizing the data is crucial. Do KPIs measure accurately, or did conversion tracking stop working? Is it challenging to compare peak and non-peak seasons because your business is seasonal? Has your company been impacted by a worldwide epidemic, recession, or supply chain problem? Without context, you’re not getting the whole picture and can’t decide how well SEO is working.

Tools for Tracking SEO Performance

These tools, which range from free to premium subscriptions, let you examine every aspect of your SEO effort, as was previously mentioned:

  • Google Analytics: A free application that offers comprehensive online traffic analytics and statistics. It lets you monitor user activity, conversions, and a plethora of other performance-related statistics.
  • Google Search Console: This is another one of Google’s free tools that provide information about a website’s performance in Google Search, including visibility, indexing status, and problems that impact ranking.
  • Ahrefs: A comprehensive, paid SEO toolset with a focus on backlink research. It provides thorough insights into the organic traffic to your website, keyword rankings, and competition research.
  • SEMrush: A strong, premium tool that offers a wealth of information on keywords, rivals, and SEO health. It also has tools for monitoring the performance of sponsored and organic searches for your website.
  • Moz Link Explorer: This tool, which is a part of Moz’s SEO toolkit, examines your domain authority and backlink profile to assist you in analyzing and planning your link-building activities.

5 Signs Your SEO Strategy isn’t Working

Not every SEO tactic produces the expected outcomes. Even though KPIs are crucial to comprehend, there are five clear indicators that your SEO approach is failing.

Organic Traffic Drops

Drops come in two varieties: abrupt and gradual. Of course, both are horrible, but for different reasons.

Abrupt declines in traffic could be the result of a change in Google’s algorithm or a sign that your website has been manually blocked. Abrupt drops are unlikely unless there is a problem with your analytics implementation or something has gone wrong with Google. whether you notice unexpected dips in traffic, ask your SEO staff whether they can explain the decline. Google Search Console will tell you whether your website has been the target of a manual action. In that scenario, it’s likely that you should stop doing business with the black hat agency.

Slow declines in traffic are a sign of a poorly implemented SEO plan. Observing a fall for a few months is one thing; witnessing a decline for numerous months or years is quite another. Of course, there could be other things at work, such as seasonal trends or COVID-19, but if you would have anticipated growth over an extended period of time and you’re not seeing it, it’s time to adjust your approach.

Content Is Falling Flat

Content that never gains traction could indicate that your approach is flawed or that the caliber of the material you are producing is insufficient. Even though you and your SEO may believe it’s fantastic, there must be a problem if it’s not generating traffic and appearing in SERPs. Although content might be unpredictable and takes time to get traction, you still want to be sure you’re getting your money’s worth. Additionally, posting blogs every month without receiving any traffic after six to a year is a sign of a poorly thought out blog content plan.

Conversions Are Going Down

It could be a sign that your SEO isn’t functioning if you notice a decline in conversions and no external reasons are at play. Somewhere along the funnel, there is a disconnect. Something is not right, whether it is the way you are attracting the correct customers to the page through keyword targeting, the content you have written specifically for them, the page’s layout and UX design, or even the conversion activity itself, like filling out the contact form. An experienced SEO specialist can identify the cause of your conversion leak and provide solutions.

Poor-Quality Backlinks

A website that has an excessive number of spammy backlinks may be punished by Google. It is often impossible to prevent spamming backlinks. It’s not always within your control who decides to connect with you. However, you have the option to distance yourself from people you don’t want to be related to. Unrelated websites, questionable directories, link farms, and overly optimized anchor text are common sources of toxic backlinks.

Possessing high-quality backlinks from reliable websites is crucial to SEO. If your backlink profile isn’t being built by your SEO team and spammy links are appearing on their own, there might be an issue. If your SEO team is using a private blog network (PBN) or buying links, you have a serious issue.

Keyword Rankings are Dropping

It’s obvious that your SEO isn’t working if you see your target keywords decline in the rankings over time. The main goal of SEO is to appear higher in Google searches, where more users are likely to click on your listings. A falling average position is a sign of ineffective on-page optimization and poor content performance. Declines in average position indicate a lack of content optimization and a slide behind emerging rivals.

Good vs Bad SEO

Effective SEO centers a plan around the methods most likely to help a company reach its objectives. It involves not just deciding on the best course of action but also having the technical know-how and experience necessary to carry it out. It’s important to execute the strategy and tactics correctly.

Effective SEO employs “White Hat” strategies. It puts improving the user experience ahead of attempting to trick or “game” search engines. A competent SEO plan differs from a mediocre one in that it knows whether to focus on technical modifications, link development, content production, or on-site optimizations.

An underperforming plan is referred to as bad SEO. This could be the result of poor planning, poor implementation, or both.

  • Inappropriate keywords to target, technical glitches to overlook, incorrect priorities, and even “Black Hat” methods that defy search engine policies are examples of bad strategies.
  • Inadequate execution refers to not paying the required attention to quality, timing, or detail in order to succeed.

In contrast to excellent SEO, which is comprehensive, long-lasting, and user-focused, bad SEO eventually fails to improve, or may even worsen, a website’s exposure and performance.

How To Tell If Your SEO Provider Is Working

The KPIs, resources, and warning indicators provide an insight into performance. Those who are not familiar with website analytics, however, may misunderstand them. It’s crucial to question your present SEO provider about performance concerns and evaluate their response when conducting an audit.

The following are some inquiries to make of your SEO company:

  • Which keywords are the focus, and how have the rankings changed?
  • How has the last three, six, or twelve months’ worth of organic traffic changed?
  • What is the organic traffic conversion rate?
  • What is the growth in conversions during the last three, six, or twelve months?
  • Are you gaining fresh, high-quality backlinks? Which new backlinks are some instances of?
  • Which technical problems are the most urgent and have they been resolved in the last ninety days?
  • Could you tell me how well-ranked and how well-performing the content produced in the last six months is?
  • In your opinion, how well is our company doing in terms of organic search traffic?
  • Which future plans or techniques are going to be used to boost SEO performance?
  • Can you demonstrate our SEO efforts’ return on investment?

These are the kinds of queries that will keep your SEO provider alert. It is a positive thing that they are astonished to hear such meaningful inquiries. It’s important to hold them responsible. An excellent search engine optimization company will provide both the positive and the bad with equal candor.

Making The Decision – When To Look Elsewhere

It might be time to make a change if, despite giving the plan enough time to produce results, you’re regularly not seeing gains in your KPIs.

Another warning sign is poor communication; you cannot compromise on consistent, honest, and easy contact with your SEO partner. You should be kept informed at all times about the tactics being used, how your campaign is doing, and any problems that may occur. It’s a red flag if your present supplier withholds this information from you or if their reports are frequently ambiguous or difficult to understand.

In the end, you should have a partner who is dedicated to getting quantifiable returns on your investment, comprehends your industry, and communicates with you in an understandable and consistent manner.


No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *